Polly ticks.

5teep

VIP Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2018
Messages
527
Points
88
Location
Highlands
Ash Regan isn't in the SNP any more. Kate has some good ideas but her Free Church beliefs will cause issues. The problem with having Nicola leading for so long is nobody else really shone so there are a lot of unknowns.
 

noddy

Moderator
Joined
Sep 18, 2018
Messages
1,362
Points
108
Location
Canada
Free Church beliefs will cause issues.
I started watching some videos on the Lewis Revival in 1949 the other day. I think I better find out some more. The ones I saw seem, well, you know, interesting. I didn't know it even happened, let alone the way it did.
 

5teep

VIP Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2018
Messages
527
Points
88
Location
Highlands
I agree she's up front about everything.
She's against gay marriage, abortion, trans rights and while I don't think she would openly try to change existing laws, her work is bound to be influenced by her views. Her religion is not a progressive one and her belief in it is strong.
 

bushwacker

VIP Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2018
Messages
625
Points
88
Location
the beautiful south. but NOT on the island
I agree she's up front about everything.
She's against gay marriage, abortion, trans rights and while I don't think she would openly try to change existing laws, her work is bound to be influenced by her views. Her religion is not a progressive one and her belief in it is strong.
She would fit in perfectly .................. in Catholic Ireland or Victorian England
 

MaC

Moderator
Joined
Sep 18, 2018
Messages
2,949
Points
108
Location
S. Lanarkshire
I think she fits in fine in modern Scotland. I say that because an inclusive society accepts a wide range of opinions. KF is religious, openly states her opinions.

Trans rights are contentious, mostly because to have them women's rights appear to be denigrated and ignored.....then we have the Isla Graham debacle.....not all Scots are happy to accept 'Trans rights', just as not all Scots are happy to accept the 'hate speech' laws.

Personally I think both those 'laws' are untenable and ungovernable.

We'll see, but as a good atheist, I have no issues with Kate Forbes.
 

BorderReiver

Moderator
Joined
Sep 18, 2018
Messages
2,152
Points
108
Location
Northwest Norfolk
I think she fits in fine in modern Scotland. I say that because an inclusive society accepts a wide range of opinions. KF is religious, openly states her opinions.

Trans rights are contentious, mostly because to have them women's rights appear to be denigrated and ignored.....then we have the Isla Graham debacle.....not all Scots are happy to accept 'Trans rights', just as not all Scots are happy to accept the 'hate speech' laws.

Personally I think both those 'laws' are untenable and ungovernable.

We'll see, but as a good atheist, I have no issues with Kate Forbes.
This is what happens when folk with strong religious views get in positions of power.
 

MaC

Moderator
Joined
Sep 18, 2018
Messages
2,949
Points
108
Location
S. Lanarkshire
Can't really see the Wee Frees taking over though.....and Scotland still has it's 400+ year old edict that every child has a right to an education....that was boys and girls.

The original schools were church based and the Minister was often the Dominie

Personally I'm all for the French model, and if you want to educate your child in your religion, do it at the weekend and during the school breaks.
 

Saint-Just

Administrator
Joined
Sep 18, 2018
Messages
1,790
Points
108
Location
Ashford
1fcdc97dc452a35b1fd83454de316703.jpg
 

MaC

Moderator
Joined
Sep 18, 2018
Messages
2,949
Points
108
Location
S. Lanarkshire
From this side of the Border we're sorting looking on with Woah!......and truly hoping that the red tide's not going to flood into us too.
 

noddy

Moderator
Joined
Sep 18, 2018
Messages
1,362
Points
108
Location
Canada
From this side of the Border we're sorting looking on with Woah!......and truly hoping that the red tide's not going to flood into us too.
Does it work like that? I mean, it'll still be actual Scottish people voting, like, with ID and all
 

MaC

Moderator
Joined
Sep 18, 2018
Messages
2,949
Points
108
Location
S. Lanarkshire
Does it work like that? I mean, it'll still be actual Scottish people voting, like, with ID and all

I ought to have been clearer.....we don't want Labour back in power. They end up apparatchiks that stultify everything to support the Labour Party in Westminster.

Grass roots kind of thing. Don't feed the blighters, find the weed killer.
 
Top