Polly ticks.

noddy

Moderator
Joined
Sep 18, 2018
Messages
1,413
Points
108
Location
Canada
It is the crushing of freedom of speech in universities that is worrying me. We are starting to see evidence of Florida's general approach in Canada. This particular point of protest is the instrument for implementation in the US for lots of DeSantis's hatred of all independent thought.

The unpicking of social freedoms sounds odd coming from those libertarian types, but that is only because they lie about their intentions all the time. Right-wing antisemites using the charge of antisemitism to break up the coherence of the centre left has been one of the great intellectual coups of the C21st in the US and Europe. Not to say there isn't plenty of antisemitism and each and every political party, just that the right have been particularly artful and well-organized in creating a fulcrum from it.

If you look at the history of the membership of congress and senate in the US, you'll see that the number of Jewish democrats outweighs the number of Jewish republicans by thousands of per cent, yet it is the democrats suffering.
 
Last edited:

Saint-Just

Administrator
Joined
Sep 18, 2018
Messages
1,846
Points
108
Location
Ashford
fa3149d9949d1dcab99fc9ecc6bf40d9.jpg
 

noddy

Moderator
Joined
Sep 18, 2018
Messages
1,413
Points
108
Location
Canada
You'll be getting Kate Forbes, I reckon. Though she presents as a vicious, right-wing wifey type, inclined to supply a version of Thatcherism with a bit of anti-abortion sentiment, I am sure I am wrong about that. It is what is good and dreadful about nationalist parties .... everyone is in there from left to right and you can't tell from one minute to the next who you'll get at the top.

Rather looking forward to Rish getting eaten alive during the week. He's mumbling about 100 days of retribution (er, new and attractive policies) though. Liz and Kemi and IDS are just waiting til Friday to demand a new leader. BJ will be back in national politics by mid June.
 

Greg

Explorer
Joined
Feb 4, 2023
Messages
961
Points
88
Location
Toronto
I just finished season two of 'Things Fell Apart'

I think some of you would quite enjoy it. I thought the first season more interesting than the second. It was produced for Radio 4 and traces the history of some of the flashpoints of the culture wars.
 

noddy

Moderator
Joined
Sep 18, 2018
Messages
1,413
Points
108
Location
Canada
I just finished season two of 'Things Fell Apart'

I think some of you would quite enjoy it. I thought the first season more interesting than the second. It was produced for Radio 4 and traces the history of some of the flashpoints of the culture wars.
I found it a bit superficial, but that might have been because it was all still so fresh in the memory. It'll be valuable later to remind how crazed and gullible people became.
 

Greg

Explorer
Joined
Feb 4, 2023
Messages
961
Points
88
Location
Toronto
I found it a bit superficial, but that might have been because it was all still so fresh in the memory. It'll be valuable later to remind how crazed and gullible people became.

The second season? I agree. Part of what made season 1 interesting was tracing the history of the topics. The COVID stuff is interesting in its way but so fresh in comparison and the stories just aren't as interesting.

You'd think he would have covered Andrew Wakefield for example in the second season.
 

5teep

VIP Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2018
Messages
580
Points
88
Location
Highlands
Swinney is a steady hand, not sure that's what's needed just now but at least he will not be an easy target for the unionist machine.
 

MaC

Moderator
Joined
Sep 18, 2018
Messages
3,012
Points
108
Location
S. Lanarkshire
I think so too.
Sound, and he's been there, seen it all, knows the characters, etc.,

I don't think I like Ash Regan, though I did like Kate Forbes.

We'll see what we see.
 

5teep

VIP Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2018
Messages
580
Points
88
Location
Highlands
I think so too.
Sound, and he's been there, seen it all, knows the characters, etc.,

I don't think I like Ash Regan, though I did like Kate Forbes.

We'll see what we see.
Regan is out of it anyway, thanks goodness she went to annoy Alba :D
 

noddy

Moderator
Joined
Sep 18, 2018
Messages
1,413
Points
108
Location
Canada
... he's been there, seen it all, knows the characters, etc.,
Isn't that what hamstrung Hamza? Too many friendships, too many conflicting historical obligations.

Is there anyone new in there who can put a left to left of centre case for independence that will appeal to under 35s.
 

Greg

Explorer
Joined
Feb 4, 2023
Messages
961
Points
88
Location
Toronto
I think this article today by Robert Kagan in the Washington Post gives an interesting perspective that in more ways than I’m comfortable with applies to many western democracies.

Good article that - I follow a podcast on the SCOTUS and have heard much of this analysis previously but in disparate conversation.
 

MaC

Moderator
Joined
Sep 18, 2018
Messages
3,012
Points
108
Location
S. Lanarkshire
Isn't that what hamstrung Hamza? Too many friendships, too many conflicting historical obligations.

Is there anyone new in there who can put a left to left of centre case for independence that will appeal to under 35s.

Thing is you see, most of them were quite happy with Nicola, so no one really thought to stir all that much to find out.

Now, well, either you go for old guard like JS or Angus Robertson, or the already divisive Ash, or go straight laced like KF. Among the younger men, Neil Gray (Health) or Jamie Hepburn....neither name is really 'recognisable' to anyone not looking hard......and that's the thing across the board.
Unless something happens that causes them to be widely reported, then most will never hear their name. Not saying they're not capable people, just not known beyond their own constituency.

It's going to be an interesting few weeks :D
 
Top